Note: This story was dynamically reformatted for online reading convenience.
 
 My Sister's Friend the Witch

   Story Codes: 1st, mgg, inc, mc, oral, preteen, rim



   My summer was looking to be a good one when school let out.  I was
turning 16 in early July, and the minute the DMV opened on my birthday, I'd
be ready to take my test and get my driver's license.  I already had my own
car parked in the garage waiting for me, and even better, it was completely
free.  It's a Volkswagen that my uncle gave to me as an early birthday
present when he bought a new Fiatt.  So from the end of May to July 9, I
had nothing to worry about and zero stress.  By the way, my name's Casey
O'Shannon.

   Actually, there was one slight thing I had to worry about.  I had no way
to pay for gas.  I'd tried applying for a job for months but every place I
went to refused to accept an application from me until I was 16.  If felt
hopeless; once I got my license, I wouldn't be able to drive my car for at
least a month, probably longer, considering how long it might take to
process a job application.  So what else could I do?  The only other thing
I could think of would be to borrow money from my mom, but I couldn't bring
myself to ask her.  She was a single mom with two kids and no child support
or alimony, since my dad split when my sister was just an infant.  I just
didn't feel right asking her for any amount of money when I had no way to
guarantee when I would pay it back, at least not unless I worked hard for
it.  But there was nothing that she needed done that was worth the amount
of money I was looking for.  It looked as if my summer was going down the
tubes before it even started.

   Then, at the very last minute, the Fates dealt me a good hand.  On the
Sunday before Memorial Day, my mom got an extremely urgent call from her
boss.  The company desperately needed her to attend a business convention
in Spain that started that Thursday.  Since it was so short notice, she
would get paid extremely well.  There was only one problem: the trip would
last three weeks.  After jumping at the offer, my mom searched frantically
for someone to look after my 12 year old sister, Caitlyn.  Unfortunately,
she had no luck.  Finally, with no other options, she turned to me.  She
offered to pay me if I cooked, cleaned, and shopped for Catie while she was
gone, and most importantly, I had to make sure she went to school.  The
school would be especially easy, since Catie only had four days left of
school, and mom would be home for two of them.  Mom's flight left after
Catie went to school Wednesday, so I only had to wake Catie up on Thursday
and Friday.  School only lasted an hour or so on Friday; the kids basically
showed up, got their report cards, and left.  Yeah, getting up early would
kinda suck, but since I had finished school a week earlier, I could just go
back to sleep once Catie left.  I gladly accepted Mom's offer.

   *********



   Wednesday went off without a hitch.  Mom got Caitlyn out the door on
time and made it to the airport ahead of schedule.  I cooked dinner when
Catie got home, and we spent the rest of the evening just hanging out in
front of the TV.  Then around 9:00 Caitlyn turned to me and asked, "Hey, do
think it would be okay if I had Lilith sleepover tomorrow night and Friday?
Like as a `kick off the summer' kinda thing?"

   She was talking about her friend Lilith Goldwyn.  The two of them had
only been hanging out for the past six months or so, but they had become
close friends.  Lilith was a year younger than Catie, but they shared the
same birthday, August 31.  I had met Lilith a handful of times before; she
was a cute kid.  She was sort of into the "goth" thing; black nail polish,
dark clothing, and hair usually dyed some sort of unnatural color.  She had
a little pentagram pendant that she'd sometimes wear around her neck, and
if you'd let her, she'd go on about different spells she could cast and
what not.  It was cute; a bit weird but harmless.

   "Sure, why not?  Bring her home after school tomorrow."

   Catie's green eyes lit up with joy.  "Thank you, thank you, thank you!"
she started, running to give me a hug.  "I owe you big time, cus I know how
mad mommy would get at you if she found out you let me have a sleepover
while she was gone."

   "Hey, she can't get mad about something she doesn't know about," I
responded casually.

   Still grinning, Caitlyn said, "I'm gonna go text Lilith right now, then
I'm getting in the shower and going to bed.  Good night!" With a flash of
red hair, she was gone up the staircase.

   *********



   The two girls arrived at the house shortly after school got out, Lilith
carrying both a large pink duffle bag and her backpack over her shoulder.
"Hey, you like my hair?" she asked with a grin as she walked through the
living room.  Her hair was freshly dyed black with bright blue streaks.

   "Yeah, it looks good," I answered.

   "Aww, thanks," she responded.

   The rest of the night was pretty much like the night before.  The three
of us sat around not doing much, just watching TV and talking.  The girls
retreated to Caitlyn's room around 7:30 to do their usual sleepover things.
I stayed downstairs, watched some more TV, and straightened up a bit.  Then
at about 10:00 I decided to hop in the shower before calling it a night.

   As I showered, I started thinking about a million different
insignificant things all at once.  I ended up getting so wrapped up in my
thoughts that I was practically unaware of everything else around me.  The
shower water had run cold for ten minutes before I noticed and turned the
water off.  Just as I turned the faucet, there was a noise that caught my
ear.  It sounded like...  giggling.  "No," I thought to myself.  "I must be
over tired so I'm hearing things." Then I heard it again, but softer.  I
held my breath for a moment so I could hear better.  There it was once
more! Convinced the sound was real, I whipped open the shower curtain, and
there they were.

   Catie and Lilith were standing directly across from me, dressed in their
pajamas.  Catie had on a white tank top and a matching pair of short
shorts, with her fiery red hair pulled pack in a loose ponytail.  Lilith
wore a dark purple and black t-shirt that just barely covered up her lower
half, as well as a pair of knee high purple socks.  She had a medium sized
purse on her left shoulder and was holding a small pouch in her hand.

   "What the hell are you guys doing?" I shouted, trying to cover myself
with the shower curtain.

   "Well, we're trying to get a look at your cock but that shower curtain's
in the way," Lilith answered nonchalantly.  "Do you think you can move it?"

   "Both of you get out of here now!" I yelled, unable to process what was
going on.

   "Aw, c'mon, it looks like you don't have anything to be ashamed of
anyway," Lilith continued.  "I can tell from here how hot your abs and pecs
are, now just let us see the main event!"

   "Yeah, show us the goods!" Catie chimed in.

   Unable to believe my ears, my face flushed with a mixture of rage and
bewilderment as I tried to come up with something to say.

   "You're not gonna play along?  Fine." Lilith said forcefully.  At that
moment, she emptied the contents of her little pouch onto the floor. 
Before I could even see what the substance was, Lilith snapped her fingers
twice, and the powder disappeared into thin air.  My nostrils suddenly
filled with the smell of burning cedar.

   "Now, Casey, come over here so we can get a good look at that cock,"
Lilith cooed at me, and before I knew what was happening, I calmly walked
across the room to the girls.  "My, my, my, you are a big boy.  And you're
uncircumcised, so that should be fun," Lilith commented as she put on a
pair of black horn rimmed glasses.  "Let's get you hard and measure it.  Go
for it, Cat."

   I watched in a surreal, dreamlike state as my younger sister reached out
with her pale, freckled hands and began slowly massaging my dick.  "Like
this?" she asked, turning to her friend for reassurance.

   "Mhmm, that's good," Lilith responded.  She dug around in her purse for
a moment.  "How cute that your first cock is your brother's." She took a
moment from searching to reach down and pull the crotch of Catie's shorts
to the side.  "Wow, Cat, you're already really wet.  Ah, here they are."
Lilith pulled out a ruler and tape measure from her purse.

   Lilith reached over to check Catie's progress.  "Alright, now I'm gonna
measure the length with the ruler.  You wrap the tape measure around the
middle to get the girth," Lilith instructed.

   "Okie dokie," Catie answered cheerfully and did as she instructed. 
"Holy cow, it's 5 inches!" Catie exclaimed a few moments later.  "What's
the length?"

   "10 inches," Lilith stated matter-of-factly.

   "Your cock is massive!" Catie said, looking up at me as I struggled to
figure out if any of this was real.

   "Well, let's get this started," Lilith said.  Catie quickly removed her
tank top and Lilith then helped remove her bra.  "God, I wish I had tits as
big as yours," Lilith said longingly.

   "They're not that big," Catie responded as she pulled her shorts down to
her ankles.

   "36B is big for 12!  You're probably gonna have D cups by the time
you're fully grown." Lilith leaned forward from behind Catie and slowly
began sucking her left nipple.

   "God, that feels good," Catie let out in a whisper.  "Alright, so I
guess I should start now, huh?" She took the base of my cock in her left
hand and slowly started moving it into her mouth.  She gently slurped at
the tip of my cock head for a minute or so then paused.  "Lil, I don't know
if I'm gonna be able to stretch my mouth that wide."

   "You'll be fine.  If anything should worry you, it'd be the length."

   "Okay, here I go..." My little sister than opened her mouth as wide as
she could and started moving my cock into her mouth.  1 inch...  2
inches... 3 inches...  4 inches...  5 inches...  This was definitely real.
With a retch, she stopped just before the 6 inch mark.  Coughing and
gagging, Catie came up for air.  "I don't think I can do this.  It's too
big."

   "Yes you can.  Just let me do something to ease your mind," Lilith said
slyly.  She made Catie bend over further and began slowly fingering her. 
Lilith then ran her tongue up and down Catie's ass crack.

   "Oh, fuck that's good," Catie let out.

   "Shut up and keep sucking," Lilith commanded, her voice muffled by
Catie's anus.

   Catie went back to focusing on my cock and picked right back up where
she left off.  She started moving faster and quickly past the 7 and 8 inch
marks.  At the 9th inch she let out a moan as Lilith picked up her pace.

   "Okay now, you fuck her throat," Lilith suddenly commanded of me. 
Without thinking, I grabbed a hold of Catie's ponytail and started
thrusting my cock into her face.  Her eyes began to tear up more and more
as my pace increased.  I then noticed her whole body begin to flush and she
began to let out loud, high pitched moans into my cock.  She was cumming.

   After Caitlyn finished her orgasm I pulled out of her throat to let her
catch her breath.  "Okay, my turn," Lilith said with a grin.  "I've been
playing with myself for the last 20 minutes anyway, so I'm pretty close
already."

   Lilith headed over to the sink and bent over, hiking up her t-shirt and
pulling her purple polka dot panties to the side.  "C'mon, show me what you
got," she taunted, twisting her hips at me.  I rushed over and shoved my
full length into her all at once.  She let out a shriek of pleasure.  "Oh!
Fuck me like your dirty little bitch.  Who's your dirty little bitch?"

   "You."

   Say it!"

   You are!"

   "That's fucking right!  Oh baby, I'm so close.  I need you to smack me
on the ass cus I've been a very bad girl."

   I did as I was told, timing the smacks perfectly with my thrusts. 
Seconds later, Lilith's voice got shriller and her hands started to twitch.
"Oh god, oh god, right there--- right there--- I'm fucking cumming!  Don't
stop, don't stop, don't stop!"

   She crumpled down onto the floor and joined her friend, trying to catch
her breath.  I stood still and silent, still fully erect.  I tried to will
myself to move or something, but nothing happened.  Finally, Lilith spoke
again.

   "Oh, look at you; you didn't get to cum yet.  Well here, I'm gonna let
you cum on my pretty face.  Or wait- better yet, you can cum on your little
sister's face!  I know you've always wanted that, right?"

   I nodded in agreement.  What was I thinking?  I had never lusted after
my sister before.  Still, I couldn't help agreeing with everything Lilith
said.

   Both girls got up on their knees.  "Alright, you better start cumming
soon, `kay?" Lilith said.  She began sucking at the root of my shaft and
tickling my balls while Catie licked at the head.

   "C'mon, Casey, I want you cum all over my little face," Catie began to
egg me on.  "Coat me, drench me, saturate me.  Bust your hot fucking nut on
me!"

   At that moment, I finally started cumming.  I shot what felt like
gallons of semen all over Catie's freckled little face.  I must have cum
for 2 minutes straight.  Catie giggled.  "You got a bunch in my eye!"

   "Here, let me help," Lilith said, leaning over to lick my cum off of
Catie's face.
   And then I blacked out.