Ami and Ashli: The Aftermath of Someone Else's Dream

by Leonard Rhine

This is the beginning of a whole new story involving my favorite (albeit fictional) twin sisters, Ami and Ashli. Enjoy the story, and please, let me know what you think.

Ami stood in the hallway wearing nothing but her pink Hello Kitty panties. She couldn't see much through the barely opened door of her father's bedroom, but she could see enough to know that he was on top of Sara, viciously and angrily fucking her ass. Ami's only conclusion was that he was punishing her for what she was doing with her and her sister, Ashli. The way Sara was screaming was confusing, however, as Ami couldn't tell if Sara was enjoying it or not.

Ami, on the other hand, was feeling a tingle in her belly and in her pussy. She decided that she didn't want to watch or listen anymore, and went back to her room. When she opened the door, all she could hear was Ashli crying.

"Ashi?" Ami said. Ashli pulled her blanket up over her head, only slightly muffling the sound of her sobs. "Ashi, what's wong?" Still no response. Ami jumped up onto the bed and put her knees right next to Ashli's covered body, sitting on her feet. "Ashi, come on, what's wong?"

Ashli threw the blanket off, sat up and yelled "Stop baby talking Ami!" and plopped back down pulling the blanket back over her head. Ashli looked like she still wasn't wearing anything.

"But you wike it." Ami protested.

"It's not funny anymore Ami!" Ashli shouted from under the blanket. "Leave me alone!"

"You're acting weird Ash!" Ami snapped back. "We were having fun before daddy came home, but now you're being a baby, so don't yell at me for baby talking, and stop being a baby and tell me why you're crying!"

The room suddenly fell silent. The twins sat in an awkward silence for what felt like an eternity before Ashli flipped the blanket down to her waist. Ami was right. She was still naked. At least from the waist up. Ashli looked up at Ami with tears in her eyes. "I . . ." she started, her voice quivering. "I thought I was dreaming, but I couldn't do what I wanted to."

"Huh?" Ami asked, confused.

"My body moved by itself and my mouth talked by itself and it was saying things I don't know how to say!" Ashli said quickly, becoming more difficult to understand as she began sobbing again. "I was scared. . . and then it felt good, and then. . . it was scary again and I . . . I was with you . . . and you were . . . and . . ." Tears poured around her face into her hair and onto her pillow. "I don't even know what happened!" she shouted as she started rubbing her eyes with her hands.

Ami quickly slid under the blanket and wrapped her arms around Ashli, pulling her close, and Ashli's sobbing stopped instantly. Ashli looked down at her sister, who was face down in her chest, squeezing their warm bodies together. "It's okay now." Ami said in a soothing voice. "It's over and I'm gonna keep you safe, Ashi."

Ashli began wiping tears off of her face again only to be surprised by Ami's lips against hers, Ami's long hair draping over her face. Ami pulled her head away from Ashli's and smiled brightly. With tears still in her eyes, Ashli smiled back and threw her arms around Ami's neck, pulling her in for a hug and another kiss.

A sudden shriek came from beyond the bedroom door. "What's that?" Ashli asked.

"Daddy's doing sex with Sara, but it's weird sex." Ami said.

"How weird?" Ashli asked.

"His thingy is in her butt hole." Ami said, sounding a little put off by the idea.

"Her butt!?" Ashli shouted in shock.

"But I think Sara likes it."

"In her butt?" Ashli asked, before getting a curious look on her face.

"Yup. She likes things in her butt I guess." Ami said casually.

Suddenly Ashli pushed Ami away and jumped out of the bed, running to her vanity. "Hey," Ami shouted. "What are you doing?"

Ashli started rummaging through drawers in her vanity. Noisily, she moved things around and slammed one drawer after another shut before opening the one in the middle and shouting "Here it is!"

"What!?" Ami shouted, confused.

Ashli turned around and held up a Sharpie marker. "Here!" she said with an extremely serious expression on her face, and with that same serousness said "Put this in my butt hole."

"What!?" Ami repeated.

"I wanna know what it feels like." Ashli said, still very serious. "So put it in my butt like daddy's thingy in Sara's butt." Ashli walked up to the bed, crawled on and put the marker into Ami's hand.

"Are you sure?" Ami asked.

Ashli said "Yes" sternly and laid down on her stomach trying to push her butt up into the air.

"Okay." Ami said and quickly poked the bottom of the marker into Ashli's ass prompting a loud yelp from Ashli. "What's wrong?" Ami asked.

"Do it slow!" Ashli shouted. "That hurt!"

"I'm sorry!" Ami shouted back. "I've never put something up someone's butt before!"

Ashli reached back and pulled her butt cheeks apart. "Can you see it better?"

"Yeah." Ami replied. She lined up the flat bottom of the marker and started slowly pressing it against the tight little sphincter, but could not get it to go in. "It's not working, Ash."

"Try turning it." Ashli suggested.

Ami began twisting and turning the marker while pushing, but still made no progress. "It's not working." Ami said, now becoming more interested in shoving this marker into her sister's anus. "What if we make it slippery, like they do when we get those rings from the store stuck on our fingers?"

"You mean the jar of slimy yellow stuff?" Ashli asked.

"Yeah!" Ami replied. "I'll go get it!" She jumped off the bed, marker in hand, and ran out the door to the bathroom, leaving Ashli belly down on the bed holding her butt open. Ashli, in all her curiosity, arched her back to reach further back and poked her finger at her butt hole, trying to figure out how it works. Not being able to get at it very well, she turns onto her back and lifts her legs up over her head, finding it much easier to poke at her sphincter.

Suddenly, Ami came running back through the door with pale yellow jar with a blue lid on it. "I got it!" she announced, not even surprised by the position her twin was in. She jumped onto the bed next to Ashli and quickly took the lid off of the jar. "Okay," she started saying. "Are you REALLY sure about this?" she asked, holding the jar in one hand and the marker in the other.

Ashli, with her legs still up in the air, said "Yeah!"

Ami shrugged her shoulders and dipped the marker into the jar, swirling it around and making sure it was almost completely covered. Standing on her knees next to her twin sister she began to poke the flat vaseline covered marker at Ashli's anus again. She twisted, turned and wiggled it around against the tiny sphincter, and without warning, it suddenly popped inside.

Ashli gasped, holding her breath until her face turned bright red, and then let out a long quivering groan.

"Are you okay, Ashi?" Ami asked.

"My butt!" Ashli said. "It's in my butt!"

Ami giggled. "You said you wanted to know what it felt like."

"Oh, Ami." Ashli said. "It tingles my belly."

Ami suddenly grew a wicked grin. "Okay, now you said you wanted to know what the thing daddy's doing to Sara feels like, so this is what he is doing to her." she said just before slamming the marker as deep as she could. Ashli shrieked at the sudden shock and a tiny spurt of liquid came out of her pussy and left a wet trail as it dribbled down her belly toward her chest. Just as quickly as she slammed it in, Ami slid the marker almost all the way out and slammed it in again, prompting another shriek from Ashli.

"Not so hard!" Ashli cried out. Ami began thrusting the marker at a steady pace, slowly pulling out, and quickly driving it in, each time making Ashli squeal, and adding to Ashli's wetness. In less than a minute, Ami was rapidly pumping the marker in and out of her sister's ass. Ashli could only make incoherent squeals of random vowels.

Ashli's body began convulsing and a thin stream of liquid came out of her tiny little pussy, splashing right onto her face and in her open mouth as she came. Ami stopped moving the marker, fascinated by what she had just seen.

After a few minutes, Ashli finally managed to catch her breath and said, "I said not so hard!" she said, almost sounding angry, just before wiggling her way out of Ami's hands.

With the marker still in her ass, she grabbed Ami and pushed her down on the bed, straddling her shoulders. In one fluid motion she dipped 2 fingers into the vaseline, pulled them out, and then quickly pressed those fingers deep into Ami's ass hole, prompting a loud squeal from Ami.

Ashli didn't waste any time before finger fucking her sister's anus as fast and deep as she could. "Ashli, wait!" Ami cried out before throwing her head back, hitting the marker in Ashli's ass causing Ashli to cry out with a loud "AAAAYYYYYY!" Ashli suddenly fell backward, pulling on Ami's sphincter and landing on the marker, her pussy sliding open on Ami's shoulder blade and grinding her little clittie over it.

Ami squirmed under her sister, burying her face into a pillow and screaming as she came, thrusting her hips around uncontrollably. Her squirming caused Ashli to cum again just moments later, gyrating her hips, grinding her pussy on Amy's back and leaving big wet streaks in her wake.

Ashli suddenly collapsed sideways, her butt poking it's marker straight up into the air, and her fingers just barely outside of Ami's anus. Breathing hard, they both stay where they are until they catch their breath. It isn't long before both of them start giggling. Ashli opens her eyes and suddenly sits straight up, almost falling back onto Ami, and shouts "Daddy?!"

Hearing this, Ami quickly turns and sits up, a massive wet spot covering her Hello Kitty panties. Standing in the doorway is their father, who looked just as shocked and dismayed as he did when he walked in on the twins going to town on Sara. The girls sat, stunned, and waited for their dad to yell, the tears already building up in their eyes.

Suddenly, their dad said "Son of a bitch." and walked back out the door, slamming it behind him. A few seconds later the twins heard him shout "Sara! Get back in my room!"

Ami looked at Ashli, and Ashli back at Ami. They both started giggling again and Ashli said, "Uh-oh, looks like someone's getting their butt weinered again."

With that, the girls both began laughing hysterically.